Last year,
around Christmas time, my niece got a baby doll as one of her Christmas
gifts. The baby doll was what she
wanted, so you would think that she would have been excited. However, all day she never touched the baby
doll, never took it out of the box and did not even look at the doll. By the end of the day she had played with all
of her other toys, except the baby doll.
As her parents asked her to place of her new gifts in her room, she took
everything but the baby doll. When her
father (my brother) handed her the baby doll she shook her shoulders and said,
"no!" "What's wrong,"
he asked her. She implied that the baby
doll was a black baby doll and she wanted the white baby doll. This statement shocked everyone in the
room. He asked her, "why do you
want the white baby doll so badly?"
She responded with the fact that she thought the white one was
prettier. One by one each family member
asked her what made the white baby doll prettier, and each time she said the
skin and her hair. That Christmas we
spent time telling all the children about how God made them all unique, different
and special. He made everyone just the
way that they were supposed to be. We
explained you can't not like someone because of their skin color because she
would be not liking a lot of her own family members. It is very important to love everyone. By the end of the day, I am pretty sure that
she got the message and she still plays with the doll today.
For me, this
was an example of Dr. Sue's "Catch-22." I wondered in my mind, did this really
happen? As an educator, I knew that I
needed to spend time talking to my niece without asking her too many questions
to discover where this behavior came from.
I explored the subject and found out that she goes to a school where
there are not many kids that look like her.
Most of the little Caucasian children are very warm and welcoming to her
and she wanted her doll baby to look like her friends. I explained to her that it is ok to like
people of all races, but we must remember where we come from. Therefore, I reminded her parents it is
important to schedule play dates with friends that look like her as well. Maybe, friends in the neighborhood or the
church but she needs to know and accept her culture. I also asked my sister in law to visit the
school and see if there are books, toys, puppets or anything that would
represent our culture within the classroom.
If she did not see anything, I told her to ask the teacher. This is important that each child's culture
is represented within the classroom.
Today, she is coming into her own little identity and she has friends of
all races. Also, we now buy her dolls
that explore all cultures.
Thank you for sharing your story about your niece. There was a study similar to your sample. The researcher provided two dolls- one white, one black to over 100 children and asked children individually which one do they prefer and which one do they think is a bad doll. Most of the children picked the white doll as their favorite doll and claimed the black doll as bad. It is very sad. Although early childhood education started to educate children to appreciate their identity and having cultural things in the classroom to represent their cultures, the media still have a lot of room to improve on equity. I like how your family spent time to explain how everyone is different and no race is superior than others. Great post!
ReplyDelete